Flagler County Florida Detective John Gaspar The ‘shutter bug’ case

November/December 2013

John M. Gaspar, CFE

    Case in point: Case history dissection

    © HEMERA/THINKSTOCK

It was another Monday morning at Flagler County (Florida) Sheriff’s Office (FCSO) Criminal Investigation Division (CID). On the first day of the workweek, we’d review all the crimes committed over the weekend and return to a plethora of police reports and messages from citizen and deputies.

I’ve always taken an interest in patterns of behavior. In my more than three decades as an investigator, I noticed that fraud and theft schemes were on the rise not only nationally but also in Flagler County. I believe this increase was in part because of a difficult economy, availability of prime victims and a greater chance of getting away with fraud over crimes of violence. Also, some prosecutors and detectives don’t always see a fraudster’s modus operandi as criminal in nature. Other factors include limited resources, unreasonable detective caseloads and prosecutors’ and police personnel’s lack of understanding of fraud crimes. This leaves many fraud victims without closure.

I think I looked at fraud differently than many other law enforcement investigators. Of course, I would be upset if someone forcibly pushed me to the ground and took my Casio watch (valued at $125) and $20 of U.S. currency from my wallet. However, if someone defrauded me out of US$10,000 in a hurricane shutters fraud scheme (later we would nickname it “shutter bug fraud”) I would be severely financially injured, possibly for the rest of my life.

My interest in fraud cases at the police department spurred me to be more attentive to the many potential schemes that were classified as civil and not criminal. These crimes left a trail of devastated victims in their wakes. In Florida, like most other states, larceny occurs when someone temporarily or permanently deprives someone of something of value (currency, property, etc.).

According to the ACFE’s Fraud Tree, larceny of cash is one of the main components of asset misappropriation; identifying it is a good place to start when investigating fraud. The next step is gathering information to see if there’s a pattern and hence a fraud scheme or an isolated theft.

FIRST 'SHUTTER BUG' FRAUD VICTIM

So, in 2006, I was at my desk in the police station at about 8:30 a.m. with my second cup of coffee when I greeted Mary, 76, a citizen with a problem. She had purchased shutters from a franchisee of Roll-Away Shutters in Florida. She explained that she’d filed a police report months earlier; she’d made numerous inquiries about it, but no one had gotten back to her. I pulled the report up and saw that it was marked as a civil case information report and not a crime; that was why I wasn’t aware of the incident.

One of the things I learned as a NYPD detective working out of major case squad in Manhattan is to be an active listener. You learn a lot in life by just shutting up and paying attention. So I listened to Mary as she explained that she purchased shutters from a man named Daniel Quinn through a salesman named John more than 18 months previously. They took a 50 percent deposit. The State of Florida only allows 10 percent down on a purchase unless the work is completed within a designated time.

I asked Mary questions that would help me identify if this was a civil or criminal matter. Best practices, time and training via the ACFE had helped develop a skill set that would allow me to see beyond the veneer of the initial police report and look for information that may indicate the incident may not have been civil in nature. As a CFE since 1989, I’ve been exposed to a highly qualified and dedicated community of anti-fraud experts, and I’ve shared information with them about fraud schemes.

MY INITIAL INTERVIEW WITH MARY

Q: What efforts have you made to contact Mr. Daniel Quinn?

A: I called and wrote to him on numerous occasions, and he has not contacted me.

Q: Do you have phone records?

A: I do and I’ll bring them to you.

Her phone records showed she had called Quinn more than 30 times in the previous year; each call lasted about one to three minutes each. That coincided with her account that when she had left numerous messages on Quinn’s company voice mail. It’s important to have a witness’ testimonial evidence supported by forensic evidence for a good prosecutable case.

Q: Did you ever write Mr. Quinn about this business transaction, and if so, do you have a copy of that or those letters?

A: I did, and I can bring you those letters.

Mary provided me with several letters she had sent certified return mail in which she wrote that she wanted either the job completed or an immediate refund. Quinn’s business accepted some of these letters, and others came back stamped undeliverable.

At this initial stage of the investigation, I established that this was not a civil matter and it may be criminal because any reasonable person would believe that for 18 months Mary had $2,500 less in her bank account and no hurricane shutters.

In our police department, we would distinguish a civil complaint from a prosecutable criminal complaint by identifying if:

 

  1. The complainant made and documented reasonable efforts to resolve the compliant.

  2. The contractor made reasonable efforts to resolve the issue and return the deposit, funds or property.

 

 


For full access to story, members may sign in here.

Not a member? Click here to Join Now and access the full article.You must be logged in to leave a comment...

ADD COMMENT

 

TEXT ONLY 2000 CHARACTER LIMIT

Related Links

2013 CFE Exam Prep Course, US Edition2013 CFE Exam Prep Toolkit, US Edition2013 Fraud Examiners Manual, US EditionACFE Fraud Casebook BundleBribery and Corruption CasebookFinancial Statement Fraud Casebook: Baking the Ledgers and Cooking the BooksFraud Casebook: Lessons from the Bad Side of Business

 

Download Article

ABOUT THE ACFE

MEMBERSHIP & CERTIFICATION

EVENTS, TRAINING & PRODUCTS

FRAUD RESOURCES

CAREER

COMMUNITY

© 2016 Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, Inc. All rights reserved. 

Home Equity Theft

This blog article is dedicated to informing the consumer public and the legal profession about Home Equity Theft issues. There are various forms of Home Equity Theft and links to news reports & other informational sources from throughout the country about the victims of Home Equity Theft and what government authorities and others are doing about it.

Florida Builders Face Criminal Charges Of Misapplication Of Construction Funds, Grand Theft, Issuing Rubber Checks

According to a recent story in the Daytona Beach News-Journal, the Flagler County, Florida Sheriff's Office has been busy investigating and charging local home builders for taking customers' money and either not performing the work contracted for, or having the work done by a subcontractor, and then not paying the sub for the work. According to the story:

  • Flagler County sheriff's Detective John Gaspar, who led two of the last three Flagler County building company investigations that resulted in arrests, said it appears to be a "trend" that local contractors and builders are involved in mismanaging their customers' money.

  • In August, investigators arrested Gregory Bleyl, owner of Osprey Custom Homes Inc., after they say he bilked 18 Russian and Ukranian immigrants out of more than $700,000. He was charged with grand theft and misapplication of construction funds and remains in the Flagler County jail.

  • And last week, authorities arrested Joseph Fasino, owner of Sandcastle Homes for operating a building scam that also involved liens on customers' homes, bad checks, and misapplication of construction funds, investigators said. Fasino is being held at the St. Johns County Jail on $287,500 bail.

In the most recent case, Herbert Heron and Noel Richardson, owners of Canterbury Estate Homes Inc. and Oxford Title Company Inc. (the company that handled Canterbury's real estate closings), were charged with grand theft, organized fraud, misapplication of construction funds and issuing worthless checks, for, among other things, allegedly taking over $400,000 from more than half a dozen people for work they promised, but never performed. For more, see Home builders charged with multiple felonies.

For related stories on:

  • Gregory Bleyl and Osprey Custom Homes Inc., see Poor economy boosts Flagler crime.

  • Joseph Fasino and Sandcastle Homes, see Another Flagler builder charged with fraud

Go here for other posts on builders & contractors accused of stiffing customers & subcontractors. contractors stiff subs customers alpha

Home Equity Theft Reporter

Orlando & Orange County Private Investigators Ready To Help You, Now!

Published in PI Magazine

AFI utilizes National Commercial DataBase systems to track, locate, and implement surveillance processes on an individual or group of individuals. These national databases are often the only practical option of obtaining information of a person's movements, habits, personal contacts, and background. This information combined with our highly-trained surveillance teams turn up the evidence that our clients need. We have the equipment and personnel to get the job done right the first time.

Whether an individual is a suspected unfaithful spouse, missing persons, a business partner suspected of selling proprietary company information, or the proverbial insurance scammer faking a personal injury, our team of discreet surveillance professionals will physically track the suspect or use covert GPS tracking and obtain the needed information. This is done in a detailed dossier report combined with photo and video evidence, if required, to make your case a success.

These features can be implemented to protect yourself against fraudulent lovers, friends, housekeepers, senior care professionals, a nanny, or tenants. AFI will give you an in-depth report on criminal history, known addresses, property ownership, bankruptcies/judgments/liens, employment history, and any driving record information/history. AFI will also handle all Polygraph Testing to ensure honesty and integrity in those you employ or surround yourself with.

Peace of mind for you and your family is imperative in today's economy. Knowing certain information up-front is the key to the security and safety of those you love.

Call Now To Speak With An Investigator:

888-697-3478

John Gaspar, B.S., M.S. MBA, C.F.E., C.S.T 

Board Accredited Investigator

Florida License # A 2800136  C 8700343

www.afipi.com

jgaspar@afipi.com

Phone : 1-888-697-3478        Facsimile: 386-845-9265

 

John Gaspar

MYSTERY SHOPPER IN DAYTONA BEACH & THROUGHOUT FLORIDA

MYSTERY SHOPPER IN DAYTONA BEACH, FL & THROUGHOUT FLORIDA

Retail theft occurs in epidemic proportions throughout the nation and here in Daytona Beach and Florida.  Many business owners, both small and large are aware that this has a direct affect on the prices consumers pay at the register.  Using Mystery Shoppers helps to protect the bottom line and allows business to be competitive and pass along the savings to the customer.  All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc offers Mystery Shoppers as a way to uncover the truth about your retail business operation.

AT YOUR SERVICE

At All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc we value our customers and work hard to collect and provide you with accurate, reliable data. We understand that the information we supply will impact your short-term and long-term business decisions, so we go the extra mile on every assignment.

For more information about our mystery shopper services, call All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc today.

 

 

John Gaspar, B.S., M.S. MBA, C.F.E., C.S.T 

Board Accredited Investigator

Florida License # A 2800136  C 8700343

www.afipi.comjgaspar@afipi.com

Phone : 1-888-697-3478        Facsimile: 386-845-9265

Daytona beach private Investigator ALL FLORIDA INVESTIGATIONS & FORENSIC SERVICES

Daytona beach private Investigator  ALL FLORIDA INVESTIGATIONS & FORENSIC SERVICES, INC.International Investigative ServicesAFI Investigators are tenacious fact finders, vindicators, collectors of information, physical & testimonial evidence.SEASON GREETINGS FROM AFIJohn M. Gaspar and the staff of All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services, Inc. wishes everyone a Joyous Holiday Season anda safe & wonderful time being spent with your families!I would like to remind you about personal safety when you are out during the Holiday Season.  After serving for more than 35 years in Law Enforcement and Private Investigation, I  have run up against a plethora of unusual circumstances and I would like to remind people to be vigilant in their everyday life to avoid being a Victim.  The GRINCH is out there looking for an easy target.  Don't let that target be You, Your Family & Friends, or your Clients. »Be Observant & Alert - Don't get distracted when in public areas»Stay aware and watch the body language and eyes of others around you»Always know where you are and where you are going»Avoid dimly lit unpopulated areas whenever possible»Stay in groups of people that you know»If possible, always wear walking shoes when going out.  It may not be stylish, but having the ability to react and move quickly may save your life or the life of someone  you care about»And Above ALL:  if you have had a few alcoholic drinks, take a cab.  Remember that an intoxicated victim, to a Grinch Mugger, is an EASY TARGET!!!AFI very much appreciates your patronage and business every year and we look forward to serving you and your Clients again in 2016THE GATHERING OF STRATEGIC INFORMATION IS THE CORNERSTONE OF AFI's INVESTIGATIVE BUSINESS*Click the link below to access a comprehensive list of our professional services:http://www.afipi.com/*AFI also has resources of global PI partners to obtain information and support caseloads in the U.S., Caribbean, and Central America. Allow AFI to be your investigative partner in gathering the evidence  to validate the facts of your case. Visit our website for additional Investigative services at:  www.AFIPI.comBe well,John M. GasparPresident / CEOB.S., M.S., MMBA, CFE, CSIEmail: jgaspar@afipi.comPhone: 888-697-3478For a complete listing of our credentials and diverse services, visit our website at www.afipi.com.To schedule a confidential meeting and retain our services, please contact us today at info@afipi.com.All Florida Investigations and Forensic Services, Inc. 140 South Beach St., Suite #200, Daytona Beach, FL 32114Toll Free: 888.697.3478JOHN GASPAR, President of AFI, is a Retired Florida Sheriff's Office Detective and NYPD Detective Major Case Squad FL.      License# A2800136, B1400220, & C8700342 To unsubscribe click here.

140 South Beach Street, Daytona Beach, FL 32114


SERVICES, INC.International Investigative ServicesAFI Investigators are tenacious fact finders, vindicators, collectors of information, physical & testimonial evidence.SEASON GREETINGS FROM AFIJohn M. Gaspar and the staff of All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services, Inc. wishes everyone a Joyous Holiday Season anda safe & wonderful time being spent with your families!I would like to remind you about personal safety when you are out during the Holiday Season.  After serving for more than 35 years in Law Enforcement and Private Investigation, I  have run up against a plethora of unusual circumstances and I would like to remind people to be vigilant in their everyday life to avoid being a Victim.  The GRINCH is out there looking for an easy target.  Don't let that target be You, Your Family & Friends, or your Clients. »Be Observant & Alert - Don't get distracted when in public areas»Stay aware and watch the body language and eyes of others around you»Always know where you are and where you are going»Avoid dimly lit unpopulated areas whenever possible»Stay in groups of people that you know»If possible, always wear walking shoes when going out.  It may not be stylish, but having the ability to react and move quickly may save your life or the life of someone  you care about»And Above ALL:  if you have had a few alcoholic drinks, take a cab.  Remember that an intoxicated victim, to a Grinch Mugger, is an EASY TARGET!!!AFI very much appreciates your patronage and business every year and we look forward to serving you and your Clients again in 2016THE GATHERING OF STRATEGIC INFORMATION IS THE CORNERSTONE OF AFI's INVESTIGATIVE BUSINESS*Click the link below to access a comprehensive list of our professional services:http://www.afipi.com/*AFI also has resources of global PI partners to obtain information and support caseloads in the U.S., Caribbean, and Central America. Allow AFI to be your investigative partner in gathering the evidence  to validate the facts of your case. Visit our website for additional Investigative services at:  www.AFIPI.comBe well,John M. GasparPresident / CEOB.S., M.S., MMBA, CFE, CSIEmail: jgaspar@afipi.comPhone: 888-697-3478For a complete listing of our credentials and diverse services, visit our website at www.afipi.com.To schedule a confidential meeting and retain our services, please contact us today at info@afipi.com.All Florida Investigations and Forensic Services, Inc. 140 South Beach St., Suite #200, Daytona Beach, FL 32114Toll Free: 888.697.3478JOHN GASPAR, President of AFI, is a Retired Florida Sheriff's Office Detective and NYPD Detective Major Case Squad FL.      License# A2800136, B1400220, & C8700342 To unsubscribe click here.

140 South Beach Street, Daytona Beach, FL 32114


All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc .

​Orlando Private Investigators, All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc .

John Gaspar | BS, MS MBA, CFE, CSIFlorida Private Investigator

image.jpg

 

Retired NYPD Detective and Florida Sheriff's Detective that has worked in:

·13th Division Homicide NYC

·Intelligence Division & Dignitary / Celebrity & Principle Protection

·Organized Crime Control

·Major Case Squad – Bank Robberies & Terrorist Activities NYC

·Economic Crime Division Supervisor – Fraud & White Collar Crime – Florida Sheriff's Office

Specialized Training

·Certified Fraud Examiner

·Master Crime Scene Investigator

·Forensic Hypnotist - Memory Retrieval - New York & Florida

·Firearms Instructor

·Defensive Tactical Instructor

Past President of the Society of Professional Investigators – members & honoree's included Robert Kennedy & Rudi Giuliani

John Gaspar started his profession as a Criminal Justice Professional in Law Enforcement in 1973, with the New York City Police Department. While with the NYPD, he worked as an Educator, Administrator, Police Recruit Instructor, Patrol Officer, Detective and Supervisor. He also served as a curriculum developer and educator in New York City Police Department's Police Bureau.

Gaspar continued to progress in his career with the NYPD, working in a variety of investigative capacities, including Detective assignments in the Organized Crime Control Bureau, Intelligence Division (Executive and Dignitary Protection), Major Case Squad (Bank Robberies and Fraud Investigations), Special Investigation Division, Terrorist Task Force, Hostage Negotiation - Kidnapping Squad, Crime Scene Forensics and Special Investigation's Forensic Hypnosis Unit.

During his tenure in Special Investigations, John became one of the 10 most experienced and highly regarded Forensic Hypnotists in the United States. After retiring from New York City Police Department, Gaspar assumed a Command Staff role as the Chief Executive Officer of a Private Detective and Security Patrol agency licensed in four States and employing 250 people. While CEO of this agency, he was elected President of the Society of Professional Investigators, (members and honored guests included Robert Kennedy and Rudolph Giuliani). For his achievements in Law Enforcement and private sector leadership, Gaspar received a Proclamation from the City of New York.

Continuing this journey of excellence at the Flagler County, Florida Sheriff's Office, Gaspar was appointed by the Sheriff as the Director of Professional Standards and Training. In that assignment, he led the agency through the process of obtaining Florida Accreditation and National CALEA recognition.

As an educator, Gaspar has enjoyed a long standing relationship as an Associate Adjunct Professor with St. John's University in New York City, and Ad Hoc Professor with John Jay College of Criminal Justice and for the past 9 years as an Associate Adjunct Professor, FDLE Instructor and recruit school trainer with Daytona Beach Community College. Gaspar also enjoys a relationship as an Adjunct Professor at Bethune Cookman College in the Social Science Department/Criminal Justice. He currently is the Crime Scene Investigations Program Coordinator for a Local Florida University.

John's areas of focus include homicide investigations, hazmat safety, forensic hypnosis interviews, financial crimes investigation and forensic auditing in criminal investigations. He is a Master Crime Scene Technician and is available as an instructor, private investigator and consultant in each of these topical areas.

 

 

Paul Strickland

senior investigator

Mr. Strickland is a Senior Private Investigator with multidisciplinary experience in:

  • Emergency Medical Services

  • Criminal Justice

  • Public Safety

Paul’s professional career includes:

  • Emergency Medical Technician-Paramedic

  • Certified Firefighter

  • Law Enforcement Officer

  • Detective, Infectious Control Officer

  • Coast Guard licensed Captain

  • Civil Process Server

  • C Licensed Private Investigator in the State of Florida

Paul Strickland during his tenure as a Law Enforcement earned the distinguished honor of both,  Medal of Valor and Employee of the Year.  Paul earned his Associates Degrees in Criminal Justice and Emergency Medical Service and contributes to his profession as a Private Investigator with over 25 years of experience in Public Safety.

 

Barry Brannon | BS

 

Mr. Brannon started his career in Environmental and Oceanographic Engineering and earned a Bachelor of Science degree in the aforementioned discipline. After working for several years in corporate and consulting positions with the Corps of Engineers, EPA and Oil, Bio Hazard & Gas industries extensive research experience was obtained in soil, fluid and chemical analysis sectors of the business. Mr. Brannon then moved into the financial sector in the Banking and Brokerage industries at the senior corporate level gaining experience in operations and business development.

Brannon applies his life experience in his career as an environmental investigator working on toxic waste and OSHA related investigations. Mr. Brannon has enjoyed the opportunity to work in a variety of investigative specialties including photographic, vehicle surveillance, forensic analysis accepting contracts through Attorneys and Insurance Companies.

In addition Brannon has a number of years working as the lead Executive Protection specialist watching over a corporate executive and his family. Barry has extensive security industry background in logistics, principle protection , assessing threat , providing safe rooms , executive driving, corporate executive and family protection services, electronic device screening (bugs and wires), business meeting and group event personnel management.

Continuing his security experience, Barry worked in senior management with the nation's largest independent monitoring facility as National Director then became President of Marlin Central Monitoring. During his management of Marlin, Barry facilitated a complete corporate operational and financial turn-around of a regional security monitoring facility building it into a nationally branded corporation as well as the largest independent monitoring facility for video monitoring, virtual guard services and alarm event verification. Barry then built a ground-up security department and monitoring facility for a Fortune 45 Corporation in the medical industry.

Barry has continued his security education and licensing to include Florida State Licenses consisting of D, G, and C. Now partnering with the vast experience of All Florida Investigations with John Gaspar, Private Investigator. This corporate team brings an extensive and well rounded knowledge of all forms of security, surveillance and investigations to work with individual, corporate, executive, and municipal clients.

 

 

John Gaspar, B.S., M.S. MMBA, C.F.E., C.S.T 

Board Accredited Investigator

Florida License # A 2800136  C 8700343

www.afipi.comjgaspar@afipi.com

Phone : 1-888-697-3478        Facsimile: 386-845-9265

 

John Gaspar

WORKERS' COMP THROUGHOUT FLORIDA

WORKERS' COMP IN DAYTONA BEACH, FL & THROUGHOUT FLORIDA

Each year, employers and insurance companies lose significant amounts of money paying out fraudulent workers compensationclaims. False claims can do more than just cost your business and insurers money; they can also create a culture of dishonesty and suspicion in the workplace. If you have reason to believe that a workers comp claim filed against your company may be fraudulent, come to All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc today. As a private investigation service in Daytona Beach, FL we have the tools to uncover the truth so that you can protect yourself financially.

HERE TO HELP

At All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc we understand that fraudulent workers comp claims are a sensitive matter. That's why we hold ourselves to the highest standards in all that we do. When you work with us, we'll conduct our investigation using the utmost discretion, all the while digging deeply to get you the answers you need.

For more information about our services or to schedule a consultation, call AFI today.

John Gaspar, B.S., M.S. MBA, C.F.E., C.S.T 

Board Accredited Investigator

Florida License # A 2800136  C 8700343

www.afipi.comjgaspar@afipi.com

Phone : 1-888-697-3478        Facsimile: 386-845-9265

John Gaspar

Process server throughout Florida

 

Legal disputes and proceedings can become all the more difficult when you can't locate the parties involved or manage to serve them with the necessary documentation. If you're in need of a process server in Daytona Beach and throughout Florida who can get the job done, look no further than All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc now. We pride ourselves in excellent service and results, and we're ready to show you what sets us apart from the competition.

COUNT ON US

At All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc, we understand the importance of timely and accurate process serving. Once engaged our process servers will commit themselves to delivering legal papers to support your legal action. We hold and conduct ourselves to the highest standards in terms of work ethic and reliability; and we bring energy and conviction to all that we do.

If you need a dependable process server in Florida and the greater Daytona Beach / Palm Coastarea who will tenaciously and legally serve your legal papers , come to All Florida Investigations & Forensic Services Inc today. Call our office for more information or to schedule an appointment.

John Gaspar, B.S., M.S. MBA, C.F.E., C.S.T  

Board Accredited Investigator

Florida License # A 2800136  C 8700343

www.afipi.com    jgaspar@afipi.com

Phone : 1-888-697-3478         Facsimile: 386-845-9265

John Gaspar